For “new economics,” look to old economists
When it comes to managing the business cycle, mainstream economics have failed rather spectacularly, their prescriptions leading to increasingly violent bubbles and busts. For this reason there have been calls for a “new economics.” To get there, perhaps we just need to rediscover forgotten economists like Hyman Minsky and Ludwig von Mises.
I was intrigued by an article by Mark Whitehouse in the Wall Street Journal last week. He described how concepts like “leverage” and “collateral,” crucial to understanding credit and commonly discussed by financial economists, remain foreign to mainstream economics.
These are concepts that Minsky understood as far back as the ’60s. His Financial Instability Hypothesis precisely describes the credit bubble and bust we’ve just been through.
Today Minsky is more frequently discussed in investment circles, but his ideas remain largely ignored by academic economics. And they certainly don’t inform policy.
Then there is Mises, who Mark Spitznagel writes in this weekend’s Wall Street Journal “predicted the depression” yet remains totally ignored by the mainstream: “How curious it is that the guy who wrote the script depicting our never ending story of government-induced credit expansion, inflation and collapse has remained so persistently forgotten. Must we sit through yet another performance of this tragic tale?”
Most likely so, since Mises is generally dismissed as a “sound money” quack.
My favorite forgotten economist is L.M. Holt, who described the debt deflationary theory of depressions in 1897. (For easier reading, I retyped it.)
Irving Fisher, who is credited with that theory thanks to a paper published in 1933, only came to it after being crushed, financially and intellectually, by the Great Crash. (Days before it he declared that stocks had reached “a permanently high plateau.”) Had Fisher read Holt, he might have understood that the market peak was a debt-financed mirage.
Instead of learning from Fisher’s mistake, economists are repeating it, advocating the inflation of a new public debt bubble to replace the private one that just burst.
This is unfortunate. If mainstream economists had the intellectual honesty to admit that their theories don’t properly account for debt, if they gave “fringe” thinkers like Minsky and Mises a fair hearing, we might discover the “new” economics that has been under our noses for a hundred years.
No comments yet.
Leave a comment
Categories
- $33 million
- 2nd amendment
- 7bankruptcy
- 911, False Flag and Government Cover Ups
- aaron russo
- Administration
- Advice
- afghanistan
- aim
- al gore
- Al Qaeda
- Alex Jones
- and if youre feeling cross and bitterish dont sit and w
- and spread sunshine all over the place
- AR – 15
- ARIZONA
- Asia
- assassination
- ASSASSINS
- atrocities
- attack
- auto loan
- Bail-Outs
- bailout
- bailouts
- Banana republic
- Bank Closure
- Bank Failures
- bank of america
- bank of england
- Bankers
- bankers selling bad debts to pensioners
- banking
- Banking industry
- Bankruptcy
- Bankruptcy Tips
- banks
- Barack Obama
- barney frank
- Ben Bernanke
- bernanke upbeat
- Big Brother
- Big Government
- blackwater
- Bloomberg
- BLS
- bob chapman
- Books
- brace
- brazil
- brian baird
- buckle up
- bullion
- bundesbank
- Canadian and Australian Prime Ministers
- car loan
- car loand
- case-shiller
- cash clunkers
- cdc
- cenate
- CEO compensation
- ceo confidence
- cfa magazine
- Chapter
- Chats
- China
- china bear market
- Chrysler
- CIA
- Civil War 2.0
- cnbc
- cnn
- coins
- Cold War 2.0
- collapse
- College
- colonial
- Commentary
- commercial
- commercial paper
- Commodities
- confescating
- congress
- congressman
- Consolidation
- Constitution
- consumer confidence
- consumer credit
- Contessa
- copyright
- copyright cartel
- Corporate governance
- Corruption
- CP
- Crash
- CRE
- Credit Cards
- Credit markets
- CSI
- Curiousities
- Currencies
- Currency War
- dallas
- david rockefeller
- david rosenberg
- Debt
- Debtor/creditor
- Declare
- deficit
- deflation
- depression
- dept
- Derivatives
- derivatives regulation
- devaluation
- dollar
- Doomsday scenarios
- Downgrades
- Dr. Marc Siegel
- Dr. Russell Blaylock
- Drug Trade
- drugs
- dutch msm
- Economic Crisis
- Economic fundamentals
- economic recovery sham
- Economic Scene
- Economy
- Economy & Stock Market
- economy crisis
- economy recession
- Edit Alex Jones
- Election '08
- emergency loan program
- Employment
- end of life
- End the Fed
- Energy & Fuel
- Energy markets
- Environment
- Escapism
- Europe's Financial Crisis
- Examples
- existing home sales
- Explanations
- failure
- fair value
- fall of the republic
- False Flag Terror
- fannie mae
- fasb
- FDIC
- Featured Stories
- Fed
- Federal Reserve
- fha
- Fiat Empire – Why the Federal Reserve Violates the U.S. Constitution
- film
- Flu Pandemic
- fnm
- fomc
- Food Shortage
- foreclosures
- Foreign Labor Markets
- FOX
- France
- Free markets and their discontents
- Fuel Shortage
- Fun With Economics
- gdp
- General Information
- geneva convention
- George Bush
- Gerald Celente
- Gerd Leipold
- germany credit crunch
- Getting
- Glenn Beck
- global
- Global Warming
- Global Warming B.S.
- Globalization
- gnp
- Gold
- gold demand
- goverment
- Government
- Greenpeace Leader
- GSE
- guide
- guillain barre syndrome
- guinea pigs
- Gulags
- gun rights
- guns
- h1n1
- Headlines
- healtcare
- health care reform
- Health Care
- health insurance
- health insurers
- Healthcare
- Hedge funds
- Helpful
- Higher Rates
- himself
- HMI
- hollywood
- home prcies
- houing bubble
- house loan
- Housing
- housing bubble
- Housing Bubble Videos
- housing starts
- HR 1207
- Human Rights
- hyperinflation
- ice caps
- illuminati
- Immorality
- Implode-Explode Fed News
- Indicators
- industrial production
- Inflation
- infowars
- initial jobless claims
- interest rates
- interment camps
- investment
- Investment banks
- Investment management
- Investment outlook
- Investor Confidence
- iraq
- iraq war speech
- Jim Rogers
- john rubino
- johnny cash I wont back down
- JOLT
- JPMorgan
- Judge Napolitano
- just put on a happy face
- kaupthing
- Keiser
- king
- la raza gang
- labor turnover
- last plane out
- layoffs
- Lead
- Legal
- Legislation
- Letters
- leverage
- liberty
- lies
- links
- Liquidation
- loan
- loans
- Lost Generation
- Lou Dobbs
- Lunch Break
- Macroeconomic policy
- Mainstream Media B.S.
- manufacturing
- MAR
- Martial Law
- mass graves
- mass layoffs
- massachusetts
- max blog
- max keiser
- Max Keiser Blog
- Max Keiser Video
- MBA
- medcine
- media
- Media Distortion
- Media watch
- mental retarded
- Merrill Lynch
- mervyn king
- mexican gang
- mexico
- Michael
- Middle East
- Middle-Class
- Militarism
- militia
- Miscellaneous
- money
- money dollar
- MONEY AS DEBT
- moral hazard
- morgage
- Morning Report
- mortgage applications
- mortgage rates
- movie trailer
- msnbc
- music video
- NAHB
- NAR
- NAU
- New World Order
- neworleans
- News
- non-farm payroll
- North American Union
- Nuclear Energy
- nwo
- obama
- Office
- oil
- on the edge
- Outsourcing
- paris
- Peak Oil
- Peter Schiff
- pick out a pleasant outlook stick out that noble chin
- PirateMyFilm
- Planet Money Podcast
- Players
- pmf
- Podcast
- police
- police brutality
- Police Crimes
- Police State
- Politics
- population control
- Poster Revolution Contest
- precious metals
- preferred
- propaganda
- Protectionism
- Protests Revolution Activism
- put on a happy face
- put on a happy smile
- quantitative easing
- quatitative easing
- Quotes
- RACE
- Rachel Maddow
- rakoff
- ran paul
- Rand Paul
- Ratings Agencies
- Real Estate
- recession
- Recession '08
- recession economy
- recovery fraud
- Regulations and regulators
- Religion
- residential
- Restructuring
- retail sales
- Revolution
- revoultion
- RFID
- rhode island
- Right
- robert kennedy
- rolfe winkler
- RON PAUL
- Ron Paul News
- Russia Today
- SAAR
- saudi billionaires
- Science & Technology
- Science, Healthcare
- Scott
- sec
- second amendment
- Senate
- September 11
- settlement
- shanghai
- silver
- slap on a happy grin
- so spread sunshine all over the place
- Social policy
- Social values
- socialism
- socialist banks
- socialized
- Soup Kitchens
- Sovereign Wealth
- stock market
- Store
- Student
- Stupidity
- Suicides
- sunlight rule
- Surveilance State
- Swine Flu
- tamiflu
- Taser
- tasers
- terror
- The dismal science
- the dollar
- THE OBAMA WATCH
- tom ridge
- Torture
- total unemployment
- Town Hall
- Town Hall meeting
- townhall meeting
- Treasury purchase program
- Tyrrany
- U.S. News
- U.S. soldiers
- uk debt market
- uk default
- uk deficit
- uk public sector borrowing
- Uncategorized
- Understanding The Crisis
- unemployment
- unemployment rate
- US bubble economy
- vaccination
- vaccine
- vaccines
- viagra effect
- Video
- Videos
- Wall Street
- war
- War on Terror
- WAR, WAR CRIMES
- Warren Buffet
- warren buffett
- Washington Politics
- waterfall effect
- wayne madsen
- we are change
- Weapons Deals
- welfare to bankers
- wells fargo
- william k black
- Wolf Blitzer
- Work
- world news
- World at War
- World Government
- World War 3.0
- Write-Downs
- Zach Lahn Owns
- zimbabwe
- zombie households
Archive
Links
- Al Jazeera English
- AL JAZEERA ENGLISH (BUSINESS)
- Americas Gone Bankrupt
- Bernanke Panky News
- Credit Fucker
- Debt Binge
- Democracy Now
- France 24 English
- Freakonomics
- Free Squat
- Fuck Bankers
- Go Sell It
- Gulag Blog
- Gulag ETF
- Implode-O-Meter
- Infowars
- iTulip.com – Video
- Karmabanque
- Kitco Forums – Economics & Politics
- Libertarian News Blog
- Local Adult Services
- Local Gay Personals
- M3 Data
- Max Keiser
- Max on Huffington
- maxkeiser.com
- naked capitalism
- NPR Blogs: Planet Money
- Paper Economy – A US Real Estate Bubble Blog
- Paper Economy’s Bubble News Network
- People of WalMart
- Revolutionary Politics
- Rolfe Winkler
- Surviving the Crash